digitisation in Europe
Progress report of the
National Representative Group: coordination mechanisms for digitisation
policies and programmes 2002
Rossella Caffo, in co-operation with Marzia Piccininno
Ministero per i Beni e le Attività Culturali
National Report: Italy
Policy scenario for digitisation
The present document reflects only the first step of a wider
research: up to now have only been considered the cultural activities carried out in the field of digitisation by
the Italian Ministry for Cultural Heritage and Activities (henceforth MiBAC) and all the institutes depending on it,
by the Regions and by some other public bodies.
At the moment, the survey has not considered the domain of universities and research that,
nonetheless, represents a very important reference in terms of training activities, research and
the creation and management of digital collections.
Terms of reference and National policy profile
The Lund Principles and
the NRG Term of reference have been acknowledged and endorsed in
Italy at the highest political level by the General Secretariat
and the Cabinet of the Minister of MiBAC
and by all the operative institutions of the ministry itself, i.e.
the eight General Directorates (Libraries and Cultural Institutes,
Archaeology, Archives, Museums, Cinema, Performing Arts, Architectural
and Landscape Treasures, Contemporary Architecture and Art) and
the four Central Institutes (Restoration, Union Catalogue of the
Italian Libraries, Cataloguing and Documentation, Book Pathology)
that deal with different aspects of Italian cultural heritage. The
same perspective is shared by the Co-ordination of the Regions,
the territorial Italian districts which have under their responsibility
the management of many cultural resources; it should be stressed
that, under Italian legislation, the Regions are entirely responsible
for museums and libraries of local authorities, which represent
the largest number of such institutions in the country. Accordingly,
Regions have issued their own by-laws.
On the basis of these preambles, all these institutions agreed on the opportunity to
implement the Lund Action Plan by organising international events concerning the digitisation
of cultural heritage during the Italian presidency of EU in the second half of 2003.
MiBAC, in order to implement the Lund Principles and Action Plan in Italy, along side the actions
undertaken by Minerva, set up by official acts:
National Commission, chaired by the Italian Representative of the NRG, Rossella Caffo,
for harmonising policies and programmes on digitisation, supporting and implementing all the NRG activities;
the purpose of the Commission is to constantly update the National Policy Profile, studying the possibilities
offered by the 6th Framework Programme for cultural heritage and organizing events during the Italian presidency
of the EU. It is supported in its activities by the 6th Service Informatics and Statistics of MiBAC, directed by
the Italian representative of the NRG;
- three Italian working groups on: Web sites
quality, Benchmarking and good practice, Metadata and inventories/accessibility, working in close co-operation with
the European workgroups within Minerva.
The national digitisation projects
The national policy concerning the digitisation of cultural
heritage has been carried out by MiBAC for many years, again in co-operation with the Regions, in particular under
the impulse of the librarian sector that is traditionally at the forefront of digitisation and attention to user
At the moment, there are six main national initiatives of digitisation representing many sectors: SBN, the Italian
Digital Library, SIGEC, the Risk Map, SITIA and SITAP. All of them involve MiBAC in co-operation with Regions and
(http://www.sbn.it) is the National
Library Service (SBN), i.e. the Italian library network created
by MiBAC with the close co-operation both scientific and financial
of Regions and Universities. SBN involves 51 nodes distributed over
the national territory and more than 1700 libraries (the National
Central Libraries in Rome and Florence, as well as state, city,
university and academic libraries and those belonging to public
and private, cultural or research institutions operating in various
sectors); the general index includes about 7 million records and
16 million locations. Some nodes are operated locally with the support
of Regions and Universities. SBN is available on line with over
50 million bibliographical researches made per year and more than
130,000 daily contacts.
SBN on line is a service available to end-users:
students, researchers and citizens in general. Users can consult
the modern book, the older books and the music databases searching
the OPAC SBN via Internet
or can consult the SBN databases via TN 3270.
(On line Public Access Catalogue - http://opac.sbn.it)
SBN database is the union catalogue of the Italian libraries that
have joined the National Library Service. OPAC provides access to
bibliographic records and loan services.
In order to render OPAC SBN more widely accessible and to enable target searches, four versions of OPAC
have been implemented with different access and usage characteristics: OPAC SBN on the WWW, OPAC SBN-Z,
OPAC SBN OLUIT, OPAC SBN text based search.
The future goal of SBN is to strengthen and improve the system,
involving even more Regions, Provinces and Universities as well
as private bodies (Finsiel s.p.a. and Akros s.r.l.) capable of providing
the necessary technical support (http://www.iccu.sbn.it/
evolind.htm). For the period 2001-2003 the financial resources
available for the SBN project are more than 26 M€.
The Italian Digital Library (BDI) is a programme co-ordinated with SBN and articulated over 3 years and has provided by MiBAC with more
than 5 M€ funding for the period 2001-2003; it aims to put
on line the Italian libraries heritage through digitisation
activities. The project started on the basis of a feasibility study
funded by MiBAC at the end of 1999 concerning digitisation initiatives
at national and international level and is led by a Steering Committee;
this commission has been able to involve several actors, such as
Universities and Regions, and also to play the role of evaluator
of the projects presented by state libraries, local libraries, cultural
institutions and universities to be funded by MiBAC within the BDI
An English summary of the feasibility study is available at the following URL http://www.ifnet.it/elag2002/papers/pap1/studio_BDI/pt_0_Summary_eng.zip; the full study is available at the following URL http://www.ifnet.it/elag2002/papers/pap1/studio_BDI/
ICCU participates in the project with a double role: digitising
its catalogues and monitoring the advancement of the BDI programme
through a questionnaire available on its Web site http://www.iccu.sbn.it/bidigit.htm.
At the moment BDI is made up of several projects involving, among others, the National Library of Turin, the Marciana
Library of Venice, the Estense Library of Modena and the National
Library of Rome. The ICPL participates in the Italian Digital Library
Project with the digitisation of images and data on book conservation
and with a working group named "Digitale e Conservazione"
(DigiCon - Digital & Conservation) that carries out research
on digital documents preservation. The research program of "DigiCon"
deals with causes of chemical, physical and biological degradation
of hardware and digital media, and defines good practices in digital
media conservation in Italian Libraries. Besides the digitisation
of periodicals and hand written catalogues, a project of digitisation
of Venetian music (ADMV) is underway in co-operation with the National
Taking advantage of the experience achieved with SBN (whose activities
are based on co-operation and integration) the BDI project identifies
exactly the tasks of the different institutions involved: the central
administration supports promotion and co-ordination activities and
provides the software for the database management and the implementation
of the Web site for on line accessibility to the images, while the
libraries that join the project choose and index the material to
be digitised and provide suggestions for digitisation projects.
The planned BDI portal has a strategic role within the homonymous project
because it aims to provide constant on line information about the
ongoing or achieved activities and to offer, through a permanent
editorial team, also the international point of view from the archive,
museum and library world.
(Sistema Informativo Territoriale Ambientale Paesaggistico (http://www.ambiente.beniculturali.it)
is the main digitisation project of the DG for Architectural and
Landscape, a GIS finalized to the preservation of the Italian landscape.
It is based on the cartography produced by the Italian Geographical Military Institute (IGMI) in the scale 1:25.000 and gathers information concerning administrative data, hydrography, climatic zones, the bound heritage according the law, etc.
This system has been planned in order to allow on line consultation for both employees and end users.
- Sistema Informativo GEnerale del Catalogo is the general informatics
system of the catalogue, developed by ICCD (see competence centres).
It gathers textual information and related documents (images, drawings,
audiovisuals) concerning architectonical, archaeological, artistic,
and demo-ethno-anthropological heritage. The project ensures the
creation of an integrated system for the unitary management of functions
and processes carried at the various levels of the MiBAC operative
structures in charge of cataloguing (http://www.iccd.beniculturali.it/
Among the benefits deriving from the project are:
- enhanced cataloguing speed with a gradual increase of information available on single Assets thanks to the introduction of minimal identifying data;
- the creation of a multimedia environment for cataloguing on the national territory capable of integrating controls on the basis of ICCD reference norms;
- the creation of software tools that are able to ensure the constant automatic alignment of data to the reference norms, to the benefit of the quality of the information produced within the entire cataloguing process;
- the unitary management of the cataloguing data flow in the sphere of the entire national structure and in every phase of the process, from the initial compilation (Superintendencies) to the final validation (ICCD);
- the constant alignment of archives established at the various levels of the institutional structure in charge of cataloguing (ICCD, Superintendencies);
- the integrated management of data and metadata: meaning information on Cultural Assets and cataloguing interventions within the territory;
- the sharing of the national informative heritage and its integrated utilisation through a unique access point.
MiBAC allocated more than 3 M€ plus VAT in the period 1998-2000 for SIGEC. The Informative System today holds more than 2,000,000 records and 600,000 co-related images.
In order to implement and bring out SIGEC and Risk Map Programmes with the involvement of regions and Universities too, an additional budget of 1,5 M€ has been allocated for 2003.
The Risk Map
of cultural heritage (http://www.icr.beniculturali.it/rischio/
rischio00e.htm) is an initiative that aims to guarantee the
protection of territory and provide the Central Administration with
instruments for scientific and administrative activities. Its main
result is the possibility of planning financial resources and preservation
The Risk Map is a tool that involves public and private bodies which deal with the preservation of cultural heritage. It collects the experience and the methodological approach of the 1975 Plan for the Programmed Conservation of Cultural Heritage in Umbria, which was the first experiment of global evaluation of decay factors extended to a whole territory; the validity was dramatically confirmed with the earthquakes of Friuli (1976) and Irpinia (1980). It is sided by the regional databases. The nodes of the Risk map are also organised on a regional basis.
The initiative consists in two activities:
a permanent operative structure (the Central Hub, c/o S. Michele, Laboratory of Physics, ICR) for the managing of all information concerning the conservation of cultural heritage on a national scale;
- survey of monument decay: an activity for an effective and timely evaluation of the condition of archaeological areas, monuments and works of art.
This system aims to harmonize the interoperability of databases of different nature, produced during the years, in particular by the ICR. Its similarities to the SIGEC system are evident but while the latter is oriented towards quantification and cataloguing of cultural heritage, the Risk Map points out its decay process and status of preservation. Anyway the two systems were created to be interoperable and will be integrated in a future System for the preservation and management of the cultural heritage.
Between 1992 and 1996 MiBAC allocated about 14 M€ for the Risk Map, while other financial resources were made available for the period 1996-1997 (about 1.5 M€) and 2002 (about 3 M€).
The SITIA project (Sistema Informativo Territoriale Integrato per l´Archeologia), elaborated by the DG for the archaeological heritage of MiBAC, is targeted to the application of new technologies to the representation and management of the archaeological real estate heritage, in order to prevent the risk of loss and plan financial and administrative initiatives. For the period 2001-2002 MiBAC funded this project with more than 3.6 M€.
SITIA will allow an easy information exchange between different administrations and will also define the basis on which the Italian Archaeological Map is going to be elaborated.
Furthermore, SITIA is targeted on three different operative levels, according to the different profiles of the users.
The DG for Archives is
realising the ambitious project called Sistema Archivistico Nazionale
Archivi - National System of Archives Archivi (http://archivi.beniculturali.it).
Its aim is to build an informative platform by gathering the experiences
of all the Italian archives and to function both as provider for
the archives and portal for the end users. It will also make available
on line not only inventories or digitised resources but also develop
a e-commerce strategy providing end users high resolution copies
Currently the 144 state archives and 19 superintendencies have their own portal Archivi, visited daily by more than
1.000 users, but they have organised their Web site in an autonomous way. On the other hand this gateway contains
rich data bases:
Arcanag, to constantly update the archives´ Web sites on line;
- Archnorm, provides detailed information on all the archive laws and
regulations; the Unesco portal says it is "the most complete data base on Italian
archival legislation from 1860 till today";
- The Digital Library: from this section it is possible to download
old or rare texts and handbooks concerning archival science
- ASAI, the Historical Atlas of the Italian Archives is a complete mapping
of the heritage of the Italian archives
A feasibility study on how to enrich and connect all these resources in a homogeneous way is underway.
system (Sistema Informativo Unificato delle Soprintendenze Archivistiche
divisione_III/siusa.html) is an ongoing project that has the
objective to create a common platform for both internal (archives,
superintendencies and DG for Archives) and public use. It represents
a joint effort of ministerial offices and the scientific world in
the body of CRIBECU (Centro Ricerche Informatiche per i BEni CUlturali
- of the Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa (http://www.cribecu.sns.it).
Presently SIUSA is in its second phase (for which 52,000 € have been allocated) which
will provide the development of the following tasks:
friendly and easy-to-use interfaces for the final users;
- a self-control system for data entry:
- a sophisticated query system for professional users.
It is worth mentioning two significant digitisation initiatives concerning private archives:
- the Fondazione Ansaldo digital Archive, that gathers all the documents produced by firms;
- the Archivi
del ´ 900 - la memoria in rete project (http://www.baicr.it/frame.html/sfondoarch.html),
in co-operation with the BAICR consortium, a network of private
The DG for Architecture
and Contemporary Art (DARC) started the ambitious project
to create a data base made up of images and text of the Italian
architects; this project has been carried out in co-operation with
Regions. At present are available on line the private archives of
architects that operated in Rome and Lazio region (http://www.archivi.beniculturali.it/
SARM/Architetti/fram_iniz.htm), while soon some other archives
reorganised by the Veneto region will be accessible.
The final goal is to build a network of archives (RADAR) using a common platform.
Among the main national
projects which deal both with digitisation of cultural heritage
and e-services provided to the citizens, must be highlighted the
on line data base (with high definition pictures) of the Comando
dei Carabinieri, Tutela Beni Culturali, the army corps
which since 1969, on MiBAC dependence, has carried out research
recuperation of the stolen artistic objects,
A large digitisation project concerning the archive and library
resources of the Italian Senate (http://www.parlamento.it/senato)
and Chamber of Deputies (http://www.camera.it)
achieved 15 M€ of funding for the period 2002-2004; the goal is
to make available on line for the end users books, archive documents,
parliamentary acts and so on.
In the light of the new perspectives opened by the National Plan
for Research and by the work of the National Commission, the Italian
Policy Profile will be refined in all its details; only the part
concerning libraries is available on line
It is also appropriate to highlight that Regions in Italy have an important role to play the preservation and management of cultural heritage and they have made strong contribution to the National policy profile, elaborated on national strategic lines.
Co-ordination of national networks
MiBAC itself is a network of bodies involved in the different domains of cultural heritage. The system is structured
on three different levels: the General Secretariat, which harmonizes all the ministry´s activities, eight
General Directorates, which represent centres of administrative responsibility, and four Central Institutes,
that have an autonomous role of research and co-ordination in the fields of inventories, cataloguing, preservation
and restoration. The operative level is entrusted to the peripheral bodies such as superintendencies, archives,
libraries, museums (17 regional superintendencies, 85 territorial superintendencies of the various sectors such as arts,
archives, archaeology, 46 state libraries, 144 state archives, 766 cultural sites including museums, archaeological sites, etc.).
The first goal of the national co-operation is to engage private or public bodies, institutions, university trusts, involved in the field of research, that are able to give a strong and updated technical support to all the NRG activities.
MiBAC has established a close co-operation with the Italian Ministry for Education, University and research (MIUR).
Also the Ministry for Innovation and Technologies and the Ministry of Communication have close contact with MiBAC in the digitisation field, in particular within the eTen programme.
The Italian representative for the digitisation activities acts on behalf of MiBAC within the technical secretariat of the inter-ministerial committee for the information society.
Moreover, co-operation has been undertaken with the following institutions and networks:
(http://www.cnit.it), a National
University Trust for Telecommunication, provides technical support
in particular for the structuring and management of cultural Web
(http://www.aib.it), the Italian
Library Association, constantly gives strong support in organizing
actions, meetings (Bibliocom, etc.) and publications connected
to the spread of the Lund Principles. AIB has a very complete
Web site, a portal to the entire world of the Italian national
and regional on-line libraries catalogues, including metadata
- The Politecnico
di Milano (http://www.polimi.it)
is one of the most representative Italian university in the field
of technological research, particularly for usability and quality
of Web sites. For MiBAC it realised a feasibility study regarding
the Portal of Italian Culture.
Ingegneria Informatica s.p.a. (http://www.eng.it)
is a private company which developed most of MiBAC main informative
systems (for instance SIGEC).
- Scuola Normale Superiore of Pisa,
partner of the cultural network Culturenet in order to study possible
co-operation in the light of the 6th Framework Programme initiatives.
- The CNR,
National Council for Research, promoted the Special Project Safeguard
of Cultural Heritage (http://www.pfbeniculturali.it/index.asp)
which involves a great number of researchers from many Italian
universities and centres. It is strongly targeted to research
and applicability of technologies to cultural heritage.
Relationships and co-ordination with other national initiatives in connection with eEurope,
e-government, e-learning, e-commerce
MiBAC has carried out some important activities in the field of e-government, following the actions undertaken by the Ministry for Innovation and Technologies, i.e. the Portal of Italian Culture and all the initiatives concerning the digitisation of cultural heritage.
MiBAC edited, on 24 June 2002, in co-operation with the Ministry for Communication and the Minerva network, within the eTEN programme, a workshop on services connected to cultural heritage and activities, concerning, in particular, copyright protection for digital contents, e-commerce and life long learning. These services are included in the e-government framework of the public administration in order to allow e-inclusion and develop synergies between public and private sectors.
eTEN (Trans European Network Telecommunications, formerly known as TEN-Telecom -
http://www.comunicazioni.it/it/index.php?Mn1=9&Mn2=85) is a programme funded
by the European Community which aims to implement trans-European
services based on telecommunications, taking care also of verifying
the market opportunities and demands.
ABSIDE (Apprendere in Biblioteca: la SocietÓ dell´Informazione contro la Discriminazione e l´Emarginazione - Learning in library: the Information Society against Discrimination and Alienation) is the main e-learning project among the training initiatives for cultural heritage institutions.
The project, undertaken within the Community initiative Equal, involves central government, regions, provinces and local communities in order to reorganise and strengthen permanent education among adults.
It is also linked to two other similar projects, LearnEast and Caribal-Edist
The main aim of the project is to create a permanent network of libraries providing e-learning training courses to the users. Didactical methodologies applied are based on the integration of open and distance learning and practical activities organised by the public libraries. The skills that ABSIDE aims to create in its users are connected to new and multimedia technologies applied to cultural heritage. Its funding for the period 2002-2003 is more than 2.3 M€.
(CREazione di Mediateche per Introdurre la SocietÓ dell´Informazione
- http://www.cremisi.org) is
a project that has already concluded (funded with about 2 M€) and
from which ABSIDE originated. Given its purpose and nature, creating
a network of multimedia classrooms in public libraries, it is deeply
connected with the national system SBN.
Mediateca 2000 (http://www.mediateca2000.it;
ospiti/progetti/frmaedia.htm) is a project aiming to spread
the multimedia culture through the net of the public libraries,
in order to promote informatic tools as a strong job support.
"Mediateca 2000 Consortium" is a network of 22 cultural
firms created from the "Mediateca 2000 Action Plan", and
promoted by the Italian government. 350 young people, mostly with
a degree in humanities, have been selected in South Italy; they
have been trained on computers, information society, digitalisation
and cataloguing, the creation and management of multimedia libraries.
The project mission is to promote ICT and "cultural heritage", produce multimedia contents, bridge the "digital divide" and facilitate access to knowledge for all the citizens. The project first goal is local development through cultural enterprises and new media.
All the firms interact with all the cultural and educational institutions, local governments and no-profit institutions to valorise the vast "cultural heritage" of our country. Until now Mediateca 2000 has benefited from of more than 11 M€ of financial resources.
on the Web is the ICCD e-commerce service permitting users
to have on-line access to the electronic catalogue of photographs
of the National Photographic Library (http://fototeca.iccd.beniculturali.it).
This is the major public collection of photographs existing in Italy,
with extremely high quality pictures, being the work of the leading
photographers working from the end of the 19th Century to the early
The catalogue currently available on the Web comprises nearly 50,000 photographs
and their relative files concerning the city of Rome and the Abruzzo region from the
middle of the 20th century until today. Copies of photographs may be ordered on-line
by noting down on special forms one´s own personal data and the reason of the request
(study, publication, exhibition, etc.). The calculation of expenses is made following the Italian regulation
(Law 14th of January 1993 n. 4, DM 24th of March 1997 n. 139, DM 8th of April 1994). Payments must be made
through a postal or bank current account or through the net by credit card. Once payment is made and ascertained,
the Sales Office delivers the order to the photographic laboratory that takes care of the high resolution acquisition
from the originals and prints the photographs included in the order by a 600 dpi laser printer.
The Fototeca Web site will be integrated by with the results of the European project TRADEX, making it
possible to manage copyright issues and buy digital copies of the photographs through the network.
Vetrina Italia is a forthcoming and innovative project on the MiBAC,
developed in co-operation with the Ministry for the Regional Affairs, that will develop
in a large area of the Rome Central Station (Stazione Termini), a complex information system
organized on a regional basis: through a portal users could have any kind of integrated
information concerning all the Italian activity sectors: tourism, commerce, transports and,
obviously, management and exploitation of the cultural heritage. At the moment this service is
available only for local users but the goal is to provide a free on-line access.
European and international co-operation
During the meeting held
in Bologna on 21st October 2002 MiBAC agreed a strong understanding
with PULMAN (PUblic Libraries Mobilising Advanced
Networks - http://www.pulmanweb.org),
the network of excellence for libraries, museums and archives, funded
by the European Commission.
Contacts with EBLIDA, the European Bureau of Library,
Information and Documentation Associations (http://www.eblida.org),
in particular with its executive committee, in order to spread the
Lund Principles and Action Plan trough one of the largest and most
representative bodies that promote the convergence of archives,
libraries and museums and address copyright issues in digital era.
(Cultural Heritage Application Network - http://www.cultivate-europe.org)
is a project funded within the 5th Framework Programme which aims
to support co-operation among archives, libraries and museum. The
network, whose Italian partner is OPIB (Ossrevatorio sui Programmi
Internazionali per le Biblioteche) is divided in two parts: CULTIVATE-EU
for Occidental Europe and Israel, CULTIVATE-CEE for the countries
of Central and Eastern Europe.
RAI, the public Italian television, is involved as principal partner in the PRESTO project,
whose goal is to develop technologies in order to preserve resources of audio
and video archives in long term and make them available.
The European Commission
funded the ERPANET project in order to establish
an expandable European Consortium which will make viable and visible
information, good practice and skills development in the area of
digital preservation of cultural heritage and scientific objects.
ERPANET will bring together memory organisations (museums, libraries
and archives). The Italian contact for ERPANET is Mariella Guercio
from Urbino University, also co-ordinator of the Italian working
group on preservation (email@example.com).
The project NEDLIB
follows the ambitious goal to build a framework in which to set
down all e-publications, according to the purpose of the national
libraries: preserve on line documents for future generations, on
the basis of the OAIS standard - Reference model for an Open Archival
Information System (OAIS). The Biblioteca Nazionale Centrale di
is involved in this project.
ICCU and the Biblioteca Nazionale Centrale di Firenze (http://www.bncf.firenze.sbn.it)
are partners of the European project TEL - The European
Born under the aegis of CENL, the Conference of European national
librarians, the TEL project is funded by the European Commission
within the 5th Framework Programme and pursues the object of developing
interoperability across national boundaries.
The Department of Electronics and Telecommunications of the University
of Florence (http://www.det.unifi.it)
is partner of the European project ORION (Object
Rich Information Network - http://www.orion-net.org)
which is an EU-funded Thematic Networks project started in July
2002. The founding consortium comprises leading European archaeological
museums and technical organisations. It deals in particularly with
the application of 3D technology to cultural heritage.
Last 7th June the National Representatives Group for digitisation of cultural heritage introduced to the European Commission an Expression of Interest for the FP6, ESCHER, i.e. the development of a network involving European Ministries of Culture or responsible institutions, which guarantee to harmonise integration of technology and adopt in their country the outputs of the research carried out by universities, research centres, enterprises and associations working in the field of applying information and communication technologies in the cultural sector.
The co-operation at the European level is also undertaken by the Regions; access to ERDF and Development Funds are widely available and used within the INTERREG Initiatives with its frameworks MEDOC and CADSES (both relevant to Italy). The Regions also gained considerable experience with the FP5 and have now submitted several EoI for the FP6. Culture 2000 is another example of successful co-operation with similar authorities and research/cultural institutes in Europe.
An official working group
on benchmarking, in charge of studying a benchmarking model of cultural
heritage digitisation policies (contact person Giuliana Sgambati
has been established in Italy under the impulse of the NRG and Minerva
activity in order to co-ordinate all the activities carried out
in the field. The group is made up of representatives from both
central and local administration and demonstrates to the shared
interest in the initiative and policies. The first benchmarking
questionnaires (devised by the European Commission within the eEurope
initiative) were sent to some Italian Institutions in March 2002.
The form is divided in two parts: the first one regarding quality
aspects, the second oriented to the quantity of data collection.
The English questionnaires were sent by e-mail, together with a
presentation letter, following contacts with the institutions.
Of the 15 questionnaires, only 11 returned; they concern:
1 national project: the Italian Digital Library (BDI);
2 regional programmes: Digital Library of Piemonte and books, films, documentary and architectonical matters of the Emilia Romagna region;
2 regional projects: Imago (Data base on the prints of the Emilia Romagna region) and data base of the preservation projects of the Emilia Romagna region;
6 local projects regarding the following libraries: Angelica, Storia Moderna, Archeologia e Storia dell´Arte, Nazionale Marciana, Civica di Fossano, Archiginnasio (Bologna).
The data collection will be continued and increased in 2003; the model will be a basis for creating a national network for evaluating projects.
Inventories and resource discovery
Available inventories - Metadata
and interoperability for resource inventories
It is opportune to point out that the Italian situation regarding inventories is absolutely fragmentary and most important projects have only a local diffusion as they funded by the Regions.
ICCU (see further, competence centres; contact
person Cristina Magliano firstname.lastname@example.org),
established a National Study Group on Metadata in 2000, made up
of representatives of many cultural institutions to compare and
co-ordinate the metadata implementation initiatives among different
cultural sectors. Its goals are:
to create a permanent observatory on metadata applications within digitisation projects;
to promote the regular application of metadata standards in the field of research and preservation of digital and non-digital documents of archives, libraries, museums;
to define a shared logical model for the metadata interoperability;
- to define a metathesaurus for the Digital Library.
The work is still being carried out within the Minerva project in co-operation with ICCD.
ICCU has already developed keys access Dublin Core within the project SBN On-Line, on the basis of the prescriptions of the European project ONE 2.
A model data collection was defined with the aim of identifying
the essential elements of the digital object, in order to share
information among institutions which use different cataloguing format.
The best approach seemed to be the definition of a minimum set of
metadata, based on the guidelines provided by FRBR (Functional Requirements
for Bibliographic Records), describing the digital resources on
the basis of the four fundamental functions of the bibliographical
records: finding, identifying, selecting, obtaining. This proposal
is one of the main results of the close co-operation with the French
Ministry for Culture; it has been also introduced to the European
working group on metadata within Minerva and was fully approved.
Two subgroups have been created: descriptive metadata and managing,
administrative and structural metadata; the first one analysed a
standard developed by a users´ task force, i.e. the Dublin Core
Metadata Element Set (DCMES) and arranged a mapping strategy, available
at the URL http://www.iccu.sbn.it/mapeta1.doc.
Furthermore, a specific glossary will be created and will be available
on ICCU Web site as soon as possible.
The second subgroup elaborated a document which provides guidelines
defining a set of managing, administrative and structural metadata,
producing an XML outline based on METS (Metadata Encoding & Transmission
Standard). This document is based on studies, implementations and
comparisons at an international level. The logical and functional
model analysed is OAIS (Open Archival Information
http://lcweb.loc.gov/standards/metadata.html); the model was created by space research but
has been adopted in some projects by libraries and archives too
(NEDLIB, CEDARS and PANDORA) and can be applied to any type of archive,
digital or analogical, because of its attention to long term preservation
and distributed filing.
The ICCD project Information Network of the Artistic, Archaeological and Architectural Heritage allows the network access to a high number of data bases that, until now, were not accessible to users, following the results of an experimental system created within the context of the European project Aquarelle. In such a way, it meets the more and more pressing demand coming from Public Administration as well as from Public and Private Institutes.
The project uses standards adopted throughout the world in the field of cultural heritage, including Z39.50 protocol, ZETA Suite platform (Finsiel), CIMI (Computer Interchange of Museum Information), BIB (Bibliographic), DC (Dublin Core) and GILS (Global Information Locator Service) profiles.
The implementation of a standard access system allows correlating network distributed typologies of data that, from a structural point of view, are not homogeneous with respect to (catalographic, bibliographic, file-related) contents and structure.
The system of access is based on Internet technologies and dialogues with data banks in line with the Z39.50 protocol.
The project networks the following catalogues:
ICCD, with a multimedia data bank comprising nearly 600,000 alphanumeric cards and nearly 400,000 correlated images that are constantly being brought up to date;
Superintendence of the Artistic and Historical Heritage of Florence and Pistoia;
Superintendence of the Architectural, Archaeological, Artistic and Historical Heritage of Pisa;
Emilia Romagna Region;
Friuli Venezia Giulia Region;
Conferenza episcopale Italiana;
With a view to making up the initial core of the Historical-Artistic Heritage Network,
the Internet user can:
make simple and/or advanced inquiries, into individual catalographic data banks, into a number of catalographic data banks of the same type (art, bibliographic and archival works, etc.) with multi-target access, into a number of catalographic data banks of different type (art, bibliographic and archival works, etc.) with multi-profile access;
obtain diversified levels presentation of textual and multimedia information on the basis of definite user profiles and in compliance with reference standards;
have access to folders, that is structured hypertextual documents that may also be associated with catalographic-type data.
Good practices and skills
Good practice exemplars and guidelines
During the Alicante NRG meeting in May were introduced some of the most relevant Italian good practices, gathered by all the MiBAC competence centres that are in charge of co-ordinating them; the following list will be completed and the data collected analysed:
- SBN on line:
is the general catalogue of most of the Italian public libraries
and provides an inter-librarian loan (http://www.sbn.it);
- EDIT 16:
is the catalogue of the XVI cent. Editions (http://edit16.iccu.sbn.it/);
Rinascimento Virtuale: census of the Greek palimpsests through MANUS software, elaborated in Italy with the support of other five European countries. This software has become an international standard
Imago is a project that aims to digitise and make available on line some important archival funds such as the Florence State Archive diplomatic fund. Until now it has received more than 6 M€ in funding
the data base of the Florence State Archive (
(Florence): virtual tour of the museum; high definition images
and correlated data base (http://www.uffizi.firenze.it/Dta/daddi-eng.html);
- Web site of Galleria Estense
(Modena): advanced interactive didactics; the virtual tour CD
won the Raffaello Prize of European Community (http://www.galleria.estense.it);
- Web site of Pinacoteca
Nazionale (Bologna): digitised inventory associated to
the images; advanced didactics (http://www.pinacotecabologna.it);
- Web site of Museo
Nazionale d´Abruzzo - Forte Spagnolo (L´Aquila) : clear
path; catalogue of images associated to technical file of the
works of art (
examines the management of Intellectual Property Rights in the
on-line commerce of digital objects. TRADEX considers available
copyright marking technologies for solving illegal copying and
proof of ownership problems in the context of multimedia objects
- Piazze Storiche
dell´Italia Meridionale: on-line project, a data-base
on architecture, history, decoration and events of 168 Italian
squares through schedules, text, 10,000 images and 4,500 architectonical
drawings. Two levels of accessibility - free and protected - to
preserve highly valued scientific data (
complete translation of the iconographic classification system
ICONCLASS from English to Italian (40,000 subjects; more than
12,000 key words). The classification system is structured like
a thesaurus in a multilingual version as a concrete experience
of interoperability of different cultural data banks
Information Network: allows the network access to a high number of Italian data bases on archaeological, architectonical, artistic and anthropological objects making up the initial core of the Historical-Artistic Heritage Network
- Photographic Library
on the Web: the ICCD e-commerce service (see point 5
competence centres) permitting users to have on-line access and
buy reproductions of the photographs of the National Photographic
- Galleria Spada:
on-line training guide for the classification and identification
of the subject of the images. The guide is based on the Galleria
Spada data bank and is linked to the Italian translation of the
ICONCLASS classification system
Four Central Institutes
and the Centro di Fotoriproduzione depend on MiBAC for the elaboration
of standards on digitisation activities, the co-operation with the
Regions, cataloguing and restoration. All of them have representatives
in the national Commission and in Minerva working groups. The Istituto
Centrale per il Catalogo e la Documentazione (ICCD
- Central Institute for Cataloguing and Documentation -
is the national institute charged with programming, planning and
defining standards in the field of cataloguing the Italian cultural
heritage, in particular the frontiers of the digitisation. Its Web
site, very rich in downloads, is an important tool of communication
The Istituto Centrale
per il Catalogo Unico delle Biblioteche Italiane e per le Informazioni
Bibliografiche (ICCU - Central Institute
for the Union Catalogue of Italian Libraries and Bibliographic Information
- http://www.iccu.sbn.it) is
the body responsible for cataloguing the book heritage and at the
moment is the most developed sector in the field of digitisation.
ICCU is responsible for SBN, the National Library Service, a network
created by MiBAC with the co-operation of Regions and Universities.
Libraries participating in the SBN project are the National Central
Libraries in Rome and Florence, as well as state, city, university
and academic libraries and those belonging to public and private
cultural or research institutions operating in various sectors.
SBN is a network which aims at providing services to end-users and
is a service available to students, researchers and citizens in
The Istituto centrale per la patologia del libro
(ICPL, Central Institute of Book Pathology -
carries out research on library materials in the field of conservation.
It contributes to define methodologies, and plays an intensive role
in solving conservation problems arising in Italian libraries. The
research activities of the Institute are carried out in its laboratories
according to the following main topics: history and technology of
library materials; biological, chemical and physical mechanisms
involved in deterioration; environmental prevention and microclimate
studies in libraries; non destructive analyses, non-invasive restoration
techniques; development and diffusion of knowledge relating to book
materials and their conservation. Specific teams are at work both
for the evaluation of perspectives in digital media preservation,
and for the digitisation of the information on book conservation.
In this framework, the finalised project for the Census of the Medieval
Bookbindings Kept in Italian Libraries (CLEM) represents a unique
source of information. The Institute provides teaching and training
on book conservation and restoration by means of a Course of Advanced
Studies. Moreover a Museum carries on programmes of education on
the making, the damages, and the safeguarding of books.
The Istituto Centrale
per il Restauro (ICR - Central Institute
for Restoration -
http://www.icr.beniculturali.it) is the body responsible for all activities
of restoration in Italy. It carries out systematic investigations
according to the influence of the various environmental factors,
also on the means to prevent and inhibit the effects, the necessary
investigations for the formulation of rules and of the relative
specific techniques of restoration and conservation interventions.
It also gives scientific and technical advice to the peripheral
bodies of the Ministry and of the Regions, provides teaching of
The participation of ICR to the European project Labs TECH, which has the aim to establish a network among European scientific laboratories, must be highlighted.
The Network is established among many internationally distinguished European research centres in the field of scientific and technological applications to cultural heritage. The initiative has the goal to realise an effective complementarity among these centres to be realised through the interchanging of know-how and joining of resources.
Regions and Province autonome, due to their statutory responsibility
over libraries and museums of local authorities, have a co-ordinating
body (more information at:
http://www.regionibeniculturali.it) and can rely on competence centres
such as Istituto per i Beni Culturali della Regione Emilia-Romagna
(more information at: http://www.ibc.regione.emilia-romagna.it).
The Centro di fotoriproduzione,
legatoria e restauro degli Archivi di Stato (CFLR,
Centre for reproduction, bookbinding and restoration for the State
Archives - http://archivi.beniculturali.it/cflr/cflr.htm)
carries out research and experimentation in the field of safeguarding
and conservation of documents. The Centre is involved in education
and training for the technical personnel of the Archives Service
and, in collaboration with the University of Rome "La Sapienza",
has set up a master for conservator. The research activities of
the Centre include studies on the structure, properties and nature
of the writing support, the composition of the graphic media, the
reasons for their deterioration and the effectiveness of the tools
to hand. Over the years the Centre has grown, installing high-tech
restoration equipment, chemistry, biology, microfilm and digital
laboratories. Highly qualified technical personnel try out new methods,
new products and new systems for conservation, reproduction, nowadays
by means of the digitisation of documents, as well.
Main digitisation training initiatives
for cultural heritage institutions
The elearning projects described above (ABSIDE, CREMISI, Mediateca 2000) have a double goal: training for library users, including disadvantaged categories, through new technologies, and developing skills of professionals of the cultural sector.
From this point of view, the workshops periodically organised by the DG for libraries and cultural institutions in order to bring professionals of the libraries up to date on the digitisation of the cultural heritage must be highlighted. The same perspective is shared at local level, where authorities run their own training opportunities.
European added value
and content framework
Quality and accessibility for Web sites
On the 17th October 2002
MiBAC edited the international workshop Quality in cultural Web
sites for the Bibliocom exposition, in conjunction with the European
Commission and AIB (Associazione Italiana Biblioteche), within the
Minerva project (documents available on the Web site http://www.minervaeurope.org/events/bibliocompapers.htm).
Bernard Smith, the head of section of the DG for Information Society
of the European Commission, participated in order to illustrate
the opportunities for the cultural heritage within the FP6 to the
participants, and Isabelle Dujacquier, the NRG for the French community
of Belgium, spoke as expert on quality of cultural Web sites. The
other speakers represented all the department of MiBAC and Universities
involved in the Italian Working Group on Quality and gave a survey
on the initiatives concerning libraries, museums, quality control
tool and accessibility. The Italian Working Group on Quality has
contributed to the refinement and extension of the Brussels Quality
Framework, which was presented on the 11th of December 2001 during
the first meeting of the Group of National Representatives, and
to the content of the document containing the Preliminary Definition
of the Minerva Quality Framework.
Its co-ordinator (Fedora Filippi email@example.com)
has also elaborated some guidelines that will soon be submitted
to the European working group. The main contributions of the Italian
Working Group on Quality can be summarized as follows:
investigation of the state of the art in Web quality, in particular: survey of existing international standards in software quality, such as ISO 9126 and ISO 9241 (the latter focused on usability - a fundamental quality aspect); analysis of the W3C Consortium criteria and guidelines for Web accessibility;
contribution to the identification, within the end user perspective of quality as defined by the Brussels Quality Framework, of the main quality "quality dimensions": content, navigation, operations and presentation;
contribution to the identification, for each quality dimension, of a set of quality attributes that can be more directly measurable;
refinement of some content and navigation criteria;
in terms of library the Web sites, research in the field showed that even if they can be easily reached by national and local repertories, they must be improved regarding their usability and accessibility must be improved;
- the concept of quality
also includes the problem of accessibility: some testers have
been analysed, in particular Torquemada, a software developed
by the Bordoni Foundation (http:www.webxtutti.it/
testa.htm), together with the fundamental standards to extend
the concept of eenclusion to the disabled people.
Many of the achievements of the Italian Working Group on Quality exploit the results of a usability method for Web applications, named MiLE (Milano - Lugano Evaluation), which has been developed by Politecnico di Milano and the Istituto per I beni culturali della Regione Emilia-Romagna as in the past by some members of the Italian Working Group on Quality. It has proved to be very effective and pragmatic for the analysis and evaluation of Web usability in general, and for cultural heritage Web applications in particular.
The Politecnico di Milano elaborated for MiBAC a feasibility study for the Portal of the Italian Culture, in which a section to be implemented by the results of Minerva European Working Group on quality of Web sites will be arranged.
MiBAC is going to inaugurate Culturalweb, the first on-line daily paper oriented towards the management and exploitation of cultural activities in Italy. Culturalweb is an important tool to radically transform the cultural sector and promote the use of new technologies applied to heritage, in accordance with the institutional duty of the MiBAC.
MiBAC, with the aim of avoiding the fragmentation of study and research initiatives in the field of preservation of tangible and intangible memories, has planned for 2003, during the Italian presidency of the EU, a feasibility study to define the characteristics of durability of digital devices according to their destinated use and create a data base of technological standards used, in order
to supply knowledge for the reproduction of digital heritage and include a technical report on metadata and information treatment and management.
Particularly, one of the most important projects in this field is the creation of a Centre of Excellence for the long term preservation of digital memory, proposed in the National Plan for Research, mentioned in the next paragraph.
A working group on the preservation of digital memory was set up. An international congress on Long Term Preservation of Digital Memories will be organised during the Italian presidency.
Research activities on digitisation
In October 2002 MiBAC elaborated strategic lines concerning the applications of new technologies to cultural heritage within the National Plan for Research, developed under the aegis of the Ministry for Education, University and Research. This plan was elaborated in co-operation with the different departments of the ministry itself (all the Central Institutes and all the General Directorates, 12 bodies in total); they are not only in charge of collecting the experiences of the peripheral administrations but also of doing applied research.
Most of the thematic issues produced absolutely coincide with the Lund priorities, focus the attention on the topics connected to the digitisation of cultural heritage and are organised as follows:
digitisation of cultural heritage, its knowledge,
decay process, conservation status and accessibility through the network;
long term preservation of digital memories;
technologies for restoration and preservation of cultural heritage.
Dissemination and enlargement
The main instrument to diffuse the Lund Principles
and Action Plan is the involvement of new countries
in the NRG. The enlargement should follow
three dimensions, i.e.:
to finalise the participation of the candidate East-European countries;
to start a dialogue with Mediterranean countries,
as well as non European countries and, in particular, the USA, Canada and Japan;
to achieve the maximum consensus from institutions, universities, private companies, directed towards to the creation of a users group in relation to Lund principles and NRG activities.
Within the digitisation activities of cultural heritage MiBAC, in order to facilitate accessibility to the network, has planned initiatives to be organized in collaboration with Regions, Universities and local administrations:
developing the Italian Digital Library;
integrating the systems SIGEC and Risk Map, the two most complex data-base systems of MiBAC. Interoperability will regard in particular the data implementation methods;
starting up the Portal of Italian Culture project, addressing the objectives defined by MiBAC the resources and the projects already funded by MIUR for more than 17 M€, with the support of private and university trusts;
increasing the participation of the Italian memory institutions in European and international projects, thanks to the European framework that NRG, the Lund principles and action plan and Minerva, the operative sector of the framework itself, represent;
developing, in co-operation with Regions and Universities, strategic lines to implement e-learning methods in the field of new technologies applied to the cultural heritage. from this perspective the main goals will be to increase ABSIDE and the ICCD elearning project based on the SIGEC/Risk Map systems;
pursuing an integrated access through a network of libraries, museums and archives;
preservation of cultural heritage.
During the Italian presidency of the EU, in the second half of 2003, within the Lund Principles spreading activities, two main events will be organised by the Cabinet of the Minister, the general Secretariat and all the General Directorates of MiBAC, in co-operation with the Regions:
Florence, 16-17th October 2003: international conference in Florence about Long Term Preservation of Digital Memories, in collaboration with the Tuscany region;
Rome, 30th October 2003: meeting of Minerva user group, in conjunction with the national conference of the Italian Library Association (AIB) at Bibliocom 2003;
Parma, 19-20th November 2003: international congress in Parma on Accessibility and Quality framework on cultural Web sites, organized by Minerva in co-operation with all the General Directorates of MiBAC, the central institutes, the Emilia-Romagna Region and Parma local authorities. The organization of the congress will be carried out within the National Commission;
Parma, 21st November 2003: meeting of the NRG, in conjunction with the congress above mentioned.
In 31st October 2003, during Bibliocom, the first European meeting of the cultural network such as Delos, DLM Forum, Erpanet, Herein and so on will be organised in co-operation with the General Directorates for Archives.
During the Italian presidency of the EU the National Commission will produce, in co-operation with Minerva working groups and supported by specialists and representatives of the university domain, the following documents concerning both national and international digitisation issues:
a paper regarding priorities, policies and guidelines for the digitisation initiatives, accessibility, e-services and so on;
a report on benchmarking activities;
a position paper on the quality of cultural Web sites.
MiBAC is also setting up a working group that aims to elaborate operative rules in the field of IPR.
The Ministry for Foreign Affairs, in co-operation with MiBAC, drew up a draft decree to be submitted by 22 December to the Parliament in order to agree to the European directive 2001/29 CE on intellectual property. In October 2003 the IST conference will be held in Milan; on that occasion some events (workshops, congresses, etc.) connected to the NRG activity will be organised.